Insurance Company Claims Numbers
- Allied Insurance Company 800-282-1446
- Brethren Mutual Insurance Company 800-241-2541
- Companion Property & Casualty 800-845-2724
- Donegal Mutual Insurance Company 800-877-9006
- Erie Insurance Group 800-367-3743
- Farmers Insurance Group 800-435-7764
- Flood Insurance Program 800-767-4341
- Foremost Insurance 800-527-3907
- IWIF 888-410-1400
- Joint Insurance Association 800-492-5670
- MAIF 800-492-7120
- Mutual Benefit Group 800-290-6361
- Ohio Casualty Group 866-255-5530
- Peninsula Insurance 800-492-1205
- Progressive Insurance 800-274-4499
- Safeco Insurance 800-332-3226
- Selective Insurance 866-455-9969
- Travelers 800-238-6225
- Zurich 800-987-3373